Ok, American Idol...

[Athena]

Who do you think will win tonight and why or why not. Would there be someone else you would have liked to see instand of the two?

[[NAKED] Young DVP]

You should add an option for "I don't give a f***". Wonder who I beat out on THAT suggestion??

If you delete this Athena I'm gonna make a mockery of you! :P

[Athena]

You are a mean, mean man, Young.

[Kamie]

I would like to see my cat on american idol. ^_^ He would attack that nasty britt guy who is obviously gay

[StealthMonkey]

Young DVP]You should add an option for "I don't give a f***"

[Low-Light]

They should randomly select someone from the audiance to win. 8)

I think american idol is That lunch meat that starts with a B and ryhmes with Lonie!

[Scorpion]

That D chick cause she's cuter even though she's jailbait.

[JDogg]

Young DVP]You should add an option for "I don't give a f***"

[@gent-Orange]

Young DVP]You should add an option for "I don't give a f***"

[HighPingedLPB]

Young DVP]You should add an option for "I don't give a f***"

[Kamie]

She ain't jail bait in GA where she lives. :)

[Zantas]

Young DVP]You should add an option for "I don't give a f***"

[Scorpion]

God you people are asses tonight. If you didn't give a ****, then don't be dicks and post about it, just move on to the next thread. You all rate up there with Airwalk tonight.

Whelp this marks the 2nd year in a row American Idol got it wrong. I garuntee you that Diana sells more albums then Fantasia. Fantasia is a gospel/RB style singer. Diana fits into the pop culture. Your going to hear and see alot more from Diana then Fantasia.

[Doc Wattson]

Fantasia is 10x more talented then Diana. I thought Fantasia was the best since the selection shows. Diana doesn't even belong in the final. Diana isn't that talented and is the worse runner up in the three years of American Idol.

-Gary-

[Scorpion]

Fantasia has a better voice, but she isn't pop culture. Diana is a Britney Spears basically, with the right produce she'll be a pop star. Fantasia is a much better sing yes, but she's no idol.

[Long Black Veil]

Fantasias voice grates my nerves.

I didn't think either of them were that great.

WHERE'S CLAY AIKEN WHEN YOU NEED HIM!>!?!?!?!?!

[ArchAngelKIng]

I like em both! They are both excellent singers. Diana has grown the most, and Fantasia was the most consistence to entire time.

Cheers,


AAK

[DarkWHITE]

the two finalists from the first season was a guy and a girl... from the second season two guys... and now from the third season two girls??? coincidence???? i think not... it's all rigged i say

[Anonymous]

and these last 2 blew ass compared to Jennifer Hudson and the black dude

[steaLer]

and these last 2 blew ass compared to Jennifer Hudson and the black dude
agreed. I thought Jennifer Hudson was the best of all. stupid voters :roll:

[kael]

yo i liked george the best. He was much better and shoulda been in it longer.

[blue]

hm... the real question is who is hotter. :) Gimme some Daina lovin

[kael]

Yeah Diana is hotter, but also younger hmmmm. Now I want Lotoya.

[Doc Wattson]

Diana is Britney Spears? Spears is a sex symble with an average voice. Diana is a a average voice who needs to go on extream make over. Diana is not a pop idol at all, she is more stage talent. Fantasia on the other hand is Macey Gray.

-Gary-

[Scorpion]

And Macey Gray was popular for all of 2 months before people really got annoyed with her voice. Personally I had to turn off the radio everytime she came on because It was so distracting I nearly had a wreck a few times.

[kael]

Yeah I agree, I do not like that type of voice at all, and she wont last that long because it will be annoying.

[Doc Wattson]

No, Fantasia won't be around years from now, but she will be around a year from now sicne she does have a unique voice (like Macy Gray) and has the American Idol Hype machine behind her. No matter what you think of her you can't discount that fact.

-Gary-

[Kamie]

Both are going to have publicity and be around a year from now. Remember Clay Aiken?

Also, Diana will be getting recording contracts and all that stuff. So, even thou she "lost", she is still getting a sweet deal out of it all.

[Long Black Veil]

yeah but Clay Aiken should of won.

He's 10x better than fat Ruben.

[Anonymous]

Clay Aiken = K.D. Lang in disguise

[Athena]

Ruben might have been a big man, but he was so lovable. And he has one of those smiles like George, you can't help yourself but to smile. They have that million dollar smile.

[kael]

I didnt like Ruben at all and he doesn't seem to be doing well as everyone else.

[Athena]

I'll get you that, but he does have a great smile.

[Long Black Veil]

Smiles all great, but it's about singing, Clay has a way better voice than Ruben.

[[NAKED] Young DVP]

Funny how Clay's the only one who didn't win, yet he's WAYYY out in front as far as success is concerned. I hate that show. I admit, I did get into it a little bit last year, but the whole concept is nothing more than 'let's promote the next Flash In The Pan semi-talented one hit wonder' Show.

It really died this year. I predict that if it IS'T cancelled next year, you will see one or two of the judges replaced. Probably Abdul and Jackson.

[Athena]

lol, I doubt they would replace Paula, the guys just thinks she's way to hot. I know my husband does, lol.

[stormFury]

Everyone knows William Hung was the winner of american idol. He got a record deal and a video out months before the 'finals'. William Hung is the winner, Fantasia came in second.

[Athena]

lol

[Scorpion]

Its funny but its true, Hung has recieved more exposure already then ANY other past winner.

I'm not sure if Fantasia is even going to make it to the likes of a 1 hit wonder, Ruben has yet to hit there. Kelly almost had 2 hits but faltered but at least she's still the promo girl being the winner of the 1st year, that and she's hot.

And, yeah I think Randy Jackson might get the boot for next season. I wonder if they are going to do another world idol too hehe, that show was a major flop.

[Long Black Veil]

Naw dawg Randy Jackson can't go dude.

Now way dude, dawg, dude, it's like...dude no way Randy Jackson Is diggin it dawg, word dude.


dude.

[[NAKED] Young DVP]

lol, I doubt they would replace Paula, the guys just thinks she's way to hot. I know my husband does, lol.Who said anything about them getting the 'boot'? I just think the show is dying. I'll be surprised if it makes it past one more season. They will jump off a sinking ship, not get fired.

[[BUD]Apollo]

Man American Idol is the suxors

[stormFury]

Paula Abdul looks like a monkey. That's not hot.